At Charity Navigator, we recognize the importance of Constituent Feedback, a practice whereby a nonprofit collects feedback from its beneficiaries and then utilizes what it learns in its decision-making process. In February 2021, we shared in a co-authored blog post, our intent to showcase nonprofits and their constituent feedback practices within their Charity Navigator profiles.
Today, we are pleased to feature one such organization -- Pace Center for Girls Inc., an Encompass rated organization with an overall 100 out of 100 score, which includes a perfect score of 100 within the Culture & Community beacon where Constituent Feedback resides.
At Pace Center for Girls, we understand that, for girls to change their lives, they and their families must have a voice in shaping their present and futures. This is why during the past 35 years, we have elevated the voices of more than 40,000 girls. Providing year-round academic and social services through a gender responsive, trauma-informed, and strength-based lens, Pace has used feedback to change the life trajectories of girls who are likely to have experienced risk factors associated with delinquency and adverse childhood experiences.
Utilizing feedback loops
We have invested time and effort in developing our feedback loops because they support our mission, culture, and contribute to the success of our girls. We use ‘real-time’ data to help inform our services and ensure our program addresses our participants' needs and helps enhance their strengths. We believe that our ability to listen, reflect, and act on the feedback received from our girls and their families, our team members and community partners, contributes to quality improvement efforts, enhances innovation in our programs and bolsters our social impact. Below, we share a few lessons from our implementation of feedback loops.
A collaborative approach to surveys
Feedback keeps us on track on our mission by elevating girls’ voices. Feedback not only gives Pace an opportunity to advocate for girls, but to support girls in advocating for themselves. Collecting and using feedback offers opportunities for our girls to learn how to voice opinions, problem-solve and develop self-efficacy skills. For example, girls and team members work together on selecting the questions of our service experience survey. Girls make sure the questions target issues they experience, like interactions with their teachers, and team members translate these experiences to our culture values, in this case developing partnerships with teachers. Girls and team members also work together in the interpretation of feedback and the identification of follow-up actions. Girls also have opportunities to select information that is relevant to them and work on possible solutions. At one Pace Center, girls advocated for better food and were included in the process of selecting a new food vendor. At another Center, girls advocated for more time with their counselors, and this translated into ensuring the availability of at least one counselor to respond to immediate needs.
Feedback reinforces equity in our work
We use feedback to seek to understand and incorporate different perspectives from team members, community partners and the girls and families we served. Feedback from different perspectives ensures we bring all the voices to the table when we are making decisions. With the emphasis on structural racism in the media and different events impacting our families, Pace conducted Listening Circles with team members and girls. The act of creating listening spaces nourished trusting relationships that provided opportunities for learning about the opinions, emotions and fears around structural racism that are prevalent in the communities we served.
Feedback provides agility to respond to our girls’ needs
Our feedback culture allowed for agility during the COVID-19 pandemic to adjust our service delivery model. We asked our girls and families ‘what can we do for you?’ ‘what are your challenges?’ We conducted surveys and townhalls with families that contributed to an understanding of their challenges and what services were needed. We used feedback to create new ways or modify existing ways to provide counseling and academic services. Moving to a remote environment, it was important to listen and learn about how these new forms of service delivery were perceived and were in alignment with our culture. For example, while some girls were thriving with remote services, we learned that others were struggling and needed additional support. We applied this learning to our reopening plans to provide options for our families.
Feedback supports community learning
Feedback offers team members opportunities to understand and reflect on the experiences of our girls and families and use these insights to support quality services. The process of sharing findings and seeking interpretation from team members, our girls and community partners, facilitates uncovering key issues and root causes in the communities where we live and work. In several of our communities, we have engaged in community collaborative projects to examine the experiences of girls. As part of a data-driven approach, we aligned quantitative community indicators with girls’ feedback and reflected on it with community partners. This exercise translated into strategies to support girls’ healthy development and maximized the utilization of local resources. For example, one community created cards with relevant information for youth and parents targeting reducing the issues of failure to appear in court.
Implementing a feedback loop is not an easy task, it takes time, effort, and humility. It requires for an organization and its leadership to be open to listening and adapting its practices. Pace leadership and team members have bought-into this process and support its implementation because of its contribution to equity and inclusion, as well as our social impact. Elevating the voices of our girls and their families creates greater accountability for Pace to deliver the impact our communities are asking for.
Written by Lymari Benitez, Ph.D., Senior Director of Information and Impact at Pace Center for Girls. Pace has transformed the lives of girls and young women during the last 35 years and envisions a world where they have power in a just and equitable society. Support their mission by visiting www.pacecenter.org.