Charity Navigator Convenes Consultative Council of Nonprofit Leaders
June 9, 2020
In April 2020, Charity Navigator shared its intention to launch a new experimental rating system that will expand the number of nonprofits rated from 9,000 to 100,000. The expansion will include younger and less-established charities that have not historically been rated under the current star rating system.
Throughout the process, Charity Navigator has consulted with donors, grantors, and nonprofit and for-profit leaders. In-depth interviews and surveys were conducted to inform the methodology, system design, and messaging.
In addition to increasing the reach of Charity Navigator ratings, the new experimental rating system also provides a framework that will help increase the depth, providing donors, other site consumers, and the nonprofit sector, with greater insight into the factors associated with nonprofit sustainability and mission success. Delivering on this goal will depend on Charity Navigator’s ability to identify meaningful variables that can be used to construct robust indicators and access a variety of data sources beyond nonprofit tax filings.
In order to best serve nonprofits and the donors that support them, Charity Navigator believes it is essential to continue to have conversations and elicit feedback on key decisions in Charity Navigator’s ratings and resources moving forward. Therefore, Charity Navigator decided to create the Consultative Council of Nonprofit Leaders.
An open invitation was sent to more than 16,000 individuals on May 1, 2020. With more than 350 applications received, candidates were assessed based on their prominence and professional recognition in the nonprofit sector, their record of collaboration and ability to build strong partnerships, and their ability to have an analytic and strategic mindset. Additionally, as the nonprofit landscape is diverse, it was also important that a wide spectrum of backgrounds and identities were represented on the Council. After careful consideration, 25 members were selected on Friday, June 5, 2020.
The 2020 Charity Navigator Consultative Council of Nonprofit Leaders are:
Melissa Garcia, National Latina Institute for Reproductive Health
Michelle Hamilton, Charlotte Symphony Orchestra
Goeff Hill, DonorsChoose.org
Peter Hogarth, Children of Fallen Patriots Foundation
Richard Hovland, Alzheimer's Association
H. Thomas Landwermeyer, Homes for Our Troops
Howard Learner, Environmental Law & Policy Center
Tony Morain, Direct Relief
Jenne Myers, Chicago Cares
Candace Osunsade, National Aquarium
Randy Phelps, Ph.D., Give an Hour
Gail Schechter, Housing Opportunities Maintenance for the Elderly (H.O.M.E.)
Randi Shubin Dresner, Island Harvest Food Bank
Richard Anthony Tagle, Andy Roddick Foundation
Tosca Bruno-van Vijfeijken, Five Oaks Consulting
Stephanie Williams, North Marin Community Services
This diverse team of experienced nonprofit leaders will advise Charity Navigator on various aspects of the sector, shed light on factors that influence nonprofit success, and work collaboratively to help strengthen our current and future initiatives.